Ask for Andrea by Noelle W. Ihli Summary

Ask for Andrea by Noelle W. Ihli follows three women—Meghan, Brecia, and Skye—who were murdered by serial killer James Carson after he lured them through online dating sites. After their deaths, the women become ghosts who unite from beyond the grave to stop their killer from claiming more victims. The psychological thriller blends paranormal horror with suspense as the three spirits haunt those connected to their murders while racing against time to expose James Carson and bring him to justice.

Noelle W. Ihli is an international bestselling author known for psychological thrillers that captivate readers with heart-stopping suspense and strong female protagonists. She debuted in 2021 with "The Thicket" and quickly gained recognition on BookTok, where Ask for Andrea became a sensation. Ihli's background in editing and ghostwriting, combined with her fascination with true crime, influences her gripping narratives that often explore survival against daunting odds. She lives in Idaho with her husband, two sons, and two cats.

Ask for Andrea is perfect for thriller fans who enjoy psychological suspense with a paranormal twist, particularly readers who appreciate victim-centered narratives rather than glorifying perpetrators. The book appeals to BookTok audiences and fans of authors like Riley Sager or Grady Hendrix who blend horror with emotional depth. It's ideal for readers seeking stories with strong female characters, those interested in the aftermath of violence, and anyone looking for a fresh take on the serial killer genre that prioritizes justice over spectacle.

Ask for Andrea is absolutely worth reading, having sold hundreds of thousands of copies worldwide and earning acclaim as a "gripping, wildly creative, disturbing, and utterly unforgettable" thriller. Readers praise its unique narrative structure, emotional depth, and the powerful way it gives voice to victims rather than focusing on the killer. The book's innovative blend of psychological suspense and paranormal elements creates a fresh reading experience that keeps readers holding their breath while turning pages. Available on Kindle Unlimited, it's consistently recommended as a must-read thriller.

Ask for Andrea distinguishes itself by telling the entire story from the perspectives of the three murdered women rather than the killer, reflecting a significant shift toward victim-centered narratives in thriller fiction. The paranormal element—where Meghan, Brecia, and Skye become ghosts working together—adds a unique supernatural dimension rarely seen in psychological thrillers. This approach allows readers to experience the victims' emotions, witness their desperate attempts to protect others, and see the devastating impact on their families, creating both a thriller and a story about friendship and resilience.

Ask for Andrea explores the terrifying reality of online dating predators through James Carson, who masquerades as an eligible bachelor across different matchmaking websites using multiple aliases. The book shows how Carson uses charm, good looks (described as resembling Chris Hemsworth), and carefully crafted personas to lure women into first dates that end in murder. This portrayal serves as a chilling reminder of the vulnerabilities women face in digital dating spaces, while the victims' ghostly mission to stop him emphasizes the importance of awareness and justice.

Ask for Andrea unfolds through staggered timelines told by three distinct narrators—Meghan, Brecia, and Skye—each sharing what led to their deaths and their afterlife experiences. The rotation between perspectives allows readers to slowly peel back layers of the story, understanding each woman's unique circumstances while watching their paths converge. Brecia haunts James's family home, Meghan follows Detective Domanska who discovered her remains, and Skye watches her parents unravel. The audiobook features one narrator, making an immersive read with both formats recommended to avoid timeline confusion.

Ask for Andrea fully embraces paranormal elements as its central mechanism, with the three murdered women existing as ghosts who can observe the living world and influence events. The supernatural aspect isn't just background flavor—it's essential to the plot as Meghan, Brecia, and Skye must learn to use their ghostly abilities to communicate, leave signs, and ultimately stop James Carson from killing again. This blend of psychological thriller and paranormal horror creates what reviewers call a "twisted thriller" that's both disturbing and emotionally resonant.

Ask for Andrea explores themes of justice for victims, the power of female solidarity that transcends even death, and giving voice to those silenced by violence. The book examines grief and its impact on families left behind, showing how Skye's divorced parents unravel and how Detective Domanska is haunted by Meghan's case. Additional themes include the dangers women face, the determination to protect others from harm, and finding belonging and friendship in unexpected circumstances. The narrative emphasizes that the dead deserve to be heard and remembered as people, not just statistics.

While Ask for Andrea receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, some readers note the story itself isn't super original in terms of the serial killer plot, though the narrators and pacing make it feel fresh. The single narrator in the audiobook can potentially cause confusion between the three distinct characters without visual cues from the ebook format. Some thriller purists might find the paranormal elements detract from the psychological realism they prefer in crime fiction. However, most readers agree these minor concerns are outweighed by the book's emotional impact, unique perspective, and gripping execution.

Readers who enjoyed Ask for Andrea should explore Noelle W. Ihli's other thrillers including Gray After Dark and Run on Red, which also feature strong female protagonists and psychological suspense. Similar victim-perspective thrillers include The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold and My Lovely Wife by Samantha Downing. For the paranormal thriller blend, consider The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue or Riley Sager's supernatural mysteries. Fans of the online dating danger theme might appreciate Something in the Water by Catherine Steadman or true-crime-inspired fiction that centers women's experiences.

Ask for Andrea is the first book in a series, with a prequel titled Forget You Saw Her (Book #0) expected in 2025. There's also a companion short story called The River that provides additional closure to the main narrative and is highly recommended by readers who found it to be "the ending that I needed to read". While Ask for Andrea works perfectly as a standalone thriller with a complete story arc, the expanded universe allows readers to further explore Noelle W. Ihli's world of victims seeking justice from beyond the grave.