Pope at War: The Secret History of Pius XII, Mussolini, and Hitler

Краткое содержание «Pope at War»

1. 1

   When Silence Became Complicity

   

   00:00

   00:00

   March 1939. A frail diplomat in white robes ascends to the papacy as Europe hurtles toward catastrophe. Pope Pius XII-born Eugenio Pacelli-inherits not just spiritual authority over millions but an impossible moral calculus: how to preserve the Catholic Church while the world burns. What unfolds is a story not of heroic resistance but of calculated silence, secret negotiations with Hitler, and a devastating choice to prioritize institutional survival over moral witness. Drawing on newly opened Vatican archives, this history reveals uncomfortable truths about what happens when leaders choose prudence over courage at civilization's darkest hour. Unlike popes who rose from parish work, Pacelli was forged in diplomatic chambers. Twelve years as papal nuncio in Germany gave him intimate knowledge of Nazi rise-and a preference for accommodation over confrontation. As Vatican Secretary of State, he had negotiated the 1929 Lateran Accords, securing Vatican City's sovereignty and Catholicism's privileged status in Fascist Italy. When his predecessor Pius XI died in February 1939, Mussolini celebrated: "At long last that stubborn old man is dead!" The dying pope had prepared a speech condemning Fascism. Pacelli's first act? Ordering every copy destroyed-"not a comma" would survive. His election came swiftly. German and Italian diplomats lobbied for him, seeing a more pliable figure than his predecessor. Many Italian cardinals worried about his "weakness of character," but on March 1, after three ballots, Pacelli emerged as Pius XII. The Vatican had chosen continuity over courage.

2. 2

   Secret Channels and Broken Peace

   Начать прослушивание

   Two days after his election, Pius XII assured Germany's ambassador: "It is not the Church's business to take sides in purely temporal affairs." He wrote Hitler expressing hope for "harmonious relations" and ordered Vatican newspapers to cease all criticism of Germany. What remained hidden for decades was Hitler's secret back-channel through Prince Philipp von Hessen. On May 11, 1939, von Hessen met the pope in Cardinal Maglione's apartment - unusual quarters chosen for secrecy. Speaking German, Pius expressed willingness to compromise: "Once we have peace, Catholics will be loyal, more than anyone else." Vatican archives reveal that under Pacelli's direction, orders had been given to "burn all archival material concerning cases of immorality." Throughout summer 1939, as Hitler prepared to invade Poland, he continued using von Hessen as his papal conduit. On August 26, less than a week before invasion, von Hessen conveyed Hitler's "fervent desire" for peace with the Church. Hitler identified the "racial question" as an obstacle he thought could be "avoided" if the pope maintained silence. The pope promised: "The secretum is sacred to us." When Hitler invaded Poland on September 1, the pope resisted all pressure to condemn the invasion. Cardinal Maglione told France's ambassador the pope preferred to "let facts speak for themselves." The pope repeatedly declined meeting Polish representatives, explaining he feared reprisals against forty million Catholics in the Reich. When Soviet troops joined in dismembering Poland, Cardinal Tisserant sent an impassioned plea: "Will the Holy See not protest?" Still the pope remained silent.

3. 3

   Selective Mercy and the Jewish Question

   Начать прослушивание

   Under Mussolini's racial laws, Italy's Jews faced relentless humiliation - barred from beaches, expelled from schools, fired from jobs. Some children sold cigarette papers to help families survive. The Vatican newspaper reported these oppressive laws without comment, while thousands of foreign Jews fleeing persecution languished in Italian concentration camps. The Vatican's approach was deeply problematic. The April 1939 Jesuit journal La Civilta Cattolica - whose content required Vatican approval - described Jews as "faithful imitators of all emissaries of the anti-Church" and branded them "avaricious, lust-filled traitors." While Pius XII offered no public criticism of Mussolini's anti-Jewish campaign, he lobbied for Catholics who were formerly Jews, arguing converts deserved the same rights as other Catholics. Throughout early 1942, Pius XII received detailed reports of Hitler's extermination campaign. Father Scavizzi returned from the eastern front with eyewitness accounts - groups machine-gunned into mass graves, a German officer boasting of killing mothers and children with single shots. The pope told Scavizzi he had considered excommunicating perpetrators but decided against it, believing it wouldn't stop the slaughter and might increase anger against Jews. When Scavizzi sent documentation requesting publication, the pope judged it "inopportune."

4. Глава 4

   The Church Embraces War

   On June 10, 1940, Mussolini declared war against "plutocratic and reactionary democracies of the West." Though the pope refused to ring Rome's church bells in celebration, Italy's Catholic hierarchy rallied behind the war effort. Bishop Evasio Colli urged Catholic Action members to respond "with profound duty and generosity." Father Agostino Gemelli called for all to "prepare for victory." Vatican alignment with Fascism deepened as war progressed. In September 1940, Pius XII urged two thousand Catholic Action leaders toward "loyal and conscientious obedience to civil Authorities." When Hitler launched Operation Barbarossa against the Soviet Union in June 1941, the Vatican greeted this with relief - the attack on Communist Russia transformed the war into a battle against Christianity's greatest foe. Bishops throughout Italy characterized the struggle as "holy war." Cardinal Piazza blessed troops departing for the Russian front. The Vatican had chosen its side.

   Глава 5

   Rome's Darkest Dawn

   October 16, 1943. German SS troops surrounded Rome's Jewish ghetto at dawn. Families were dragged from beds, given twenty minutes to pack. By day's end, 1,259 Jews had been seized - hundreds of yards from Vatican City, some from apartments overlooking the Apostolic Palace. Pius XII learned of the roundup early that morning, including from Princess Enza Pignatelli who pushed past guards to reach his private chapel. The pope, who had twice rushed to bombing sites, now faced an excruciating test. He summoned Cardinal Maglione to meet German ambassador Weizsacker, who warned that papal protest might endanger Vatican neutrality. Maglione merely suggested the Holy See "would not want to be constrained to say a word of disapproval." The Vatican focused almost exclusively on securing release of baptized Jews and those married to Christians. On Sunday, Germans released those deemed Catholic. On Monday, October 18, the remaining 1,007 Jews - including 105 children under five - were loaded into cattle cars bound for Auschwitz. Josef Mengele directed the elderly, children, and sick to gas chambers. Only sixteen survived. Meanwhile, Pius XII met with British envoy Osborne, discussing food shortages and remarking he "had no grounds for complaint against General von Stahel and the German police." Neither mentioned the Jewish roundup. The silence was deafening.

   Глава 6

   The Aftermath and Historical Reckoning

   When liberation came in 1945, revisionism began immediately. Italy's ambassador to Belgium claimed racial laws "found scarce application" and persecution came "exclusively" from Germans. The Vatican recast the 1929 concordat as an agreement with "the Italian government" rather than the Fascist regime. When Rolf Hochhuth's 1963 play "The Deputy" portrayed Pius XII turning a blind eye to the Holocaust, the Vatican pressured Italy to ban it. Fascist-supporting clergy escaped consequences-Father Gemelli returned to his university post and now has Rome's major Catholic hospital named after him. On June 2, 1945, less than a month after Germany's surrender, Pius XII finally addressed National Socialism, defensively justifying his 1933 concordat and chronicling Nazi persecution of Catholics. He made no mention of the extermination of Europe's Jews, portraying Catholics as the primary victims. The pope died in 1958, having "killed himself with over-work."

   Глава 7

   The Weight of History's Judgment

   Pius XII was not "Hitler's pope"-Nazism was largely anathema to him. His relationship with Italian Fascism was far closer. The controversy over his silence began almost immediately after the war. Rome's Jewish community sees things differently than Vatican defenders-the pope remained silent as over a thousand Jews were rounded up near the Apostolic Palace and sent to Auschwitz. His influence in overwhelmingly Catholic Italy was enormous-Fascism collapsed within days after Mussolini's deposition in 1943. When the world needed a voice, the Vatican chose silence. When millions needed witness, the Church chose self-preservation. These choices echo still, reminding us that neutrality in the face of evil is itself a choice-and history remembers.

   Продолжить чтение