1장
The Tribal Revolution: How Culture Transforms Organizations
In the corporate world's relentless pursuit of excellence, one book has quietly revolutionized how we think about workplace dynamics. "Tribal Leadership," published in 2008, has become required reading for executives at companies like Zappos and tech entrepreneurs across Silicon Valley. The book's premise-that humans naturally organize into tribes that determine organizational success-has influenced countless leadership programs. Based on a decade-long study of 24,000 people, authors Dave Logan, John King, and Halee Fischer-Wright discovered something remarkable: the language people use reveals their tribal stage, and upgrading this language transforms entire organizations. While many leadership books focus on individual behaviors, "Tribal Leadership" takes a radically different approach by examining how tribes-groups of 20-150 people-create culture through language and relationships. This cultural anthropology of the workplace has been praised by luminaries from Warren Bennis to Reid Hoffman for its ability to decode what makes some organizations thrive while others merely survive.
2장
The Five Tribal Stages: A Cultural Evolution
Every organization consists of tribes-natural groupings of 20-150 people who know each other well enough to greet on the street. These tribes form naturally, as though encoded in our DNA, having helped humans survive throughout history from the ice age to modern cities. When tribes approach 150 members, they naturally split into smaller groups.
What's fascinating is that these tribes operate at five distinct cultural stages, each with its own language patterns, relationship structures, and performance levels. The authors discovered that by identifying a tribe's current stage and applying specific leverage points, leaders can systematically upgrade their culture to higher performance levels.
Stage One represents the lowest level, where people believe "life sucks" and operate with despairing hostility. Fortunately, this stage accounts for only about 2% of workplace cultures, often manifesting in environments like street gangs or deeply dysfunctional workplaces where violence might erupt.
Stage Two, found in about 25% of workplace tribes, operates with the theme "my life sucks." People behave as passive victims, crossing arms in judgment with sarcastic, resigned laughter. They've "seen it all before and watched it all fail." Think of the apathetic DMV employee or the disengaged service representative who does the minimum required.
Stage Three dominates about 49% of workplace cultures with the theme "I'm great" (and by implication, "you're not"). These high-achieving individuals must win personally, outworking and outthinking competitors individually. They hoard knowledge as power and complain about insufficient time and incompetent support. Our educational system, with its emphasis on individual grades and test scores, reinforces this stage.
Stage Four represents about 22% of workplace cultures with the theme "we're great" (and they're not). These tribes require an adversary-the bigger the foe, the more powerful the tribe. People see themselves as part of something larger, commit to shared values, and hold each other accountable. They won't tolerate personal agendas or Stage Three behavior.
Stage Five, representing less than 2% of workplace cultures, operates with the theme "life is great" and focuses on making history rather than beating competitors. The mood is one of "innocent wonderment," with people competing with what's possible rather than with other tribes. This stage produces miraculous innovations but typically occurs in brief bursts before groups recede to Stage Four.
The authors' research revealed that each progressive stage accomplishes more with greater enjoyment than the previous one. By understanding these stages and applying specific leverage points, Tribal Leaders can systematically upgrade their organization's culture and performance.
3장
Stage One: The Desperate Edge of Survival
Stage One represents humanity's darkest tribal expression-a place where "life sucks" and people act accordingly. Fortunately, this stage accounts for less than 2% of American professional workplaces, though it represents a larger percentage of society overall.
People trapped in Stage One see life as inherently unfair and hostile. They feel fundamentally disconnected from others, as though life is happening "over there" and they aren't invited. The mood is one of despairing hostility, where people surrender to appetites that often become addictions, reinforcing their belief that "life sucks."
Frank Jordan, former San Francisco police chief and mayor, has extensive experience working with people at this stage. Despite cold receptions at community events, he persistently listens to grievances and shares his own difficult childhood experiences to build rapport. His approach involves connecting Stage One individuals with mentors at organizations like Boys & Girls Clubs-essentially connecting them to tribes with higher dominant stages.
Stage One tribes typically form in one of two ways. Some people descend from higher stages until their former tribe disowns them. Others feel misunderstood by their current tribe and switch to one that "gets" them. In gang environments, loyalty becomes the primary rule, making it difficult to leave. Our prison system often reinforces Stage One culture, as inmates adopt the dominant tribal values and language, making reintegration into society more challenging upon release.
Even successful people at higher stages occasionally visit Stage One. Doctors self-medicate, professors plagiarize, and "morally upright" employees steal when they feel wronged. If these behaviors continue, people become alienated from their tribes. Some keep their addictions secret, while others create codependent relationships until their tribe performs an intervention.
Moving someone from Stage One requires helping them substitute "life sucks" with "my life sucks"-a subtle but crucial shift that acknowledges others' lives can work even if theirs doesn't. This transition often requires connecting them with tribes that don't tolerate destructive behaviors. When someone transitions from Stage One to Two, they often appear sad and disconnected rather than hostile, which represents progress despite seeming like a setback.
The key insight about Stage One is that people can't skip stages-they must progress sequentially through each one. Success indicators include using "my life sucks" language instead of "life sucks," exhibiting passive apathy rather than despairing hostility, and cutting social ties to people who remain in Stage One.
4장
Stage Two: Disconnected and Disengaged
Stage Two represents 25% of workplace cultures and is characterized by the belief that "my life sucks." Unlike Stage One, where "life sucks" for everyone, people at Stage Two can see others' lives working well while theirs doesn't. They feel victimized by circumstances and believe they can't gain traction for their ideas or ambitions.
From the outside, Stage Two is visible in organizations people love to hate-DMVs, slow-moving doctor's offices, or airport security with indifferent staff. When presented with new initiatives, they respond with cynical resignation: "We tried that before, and it didn't work then and won't work now." They typically do the minimum work necessary to get by.
Roger's story illustrates how toxic leadership creates Stage Two cultures. After discovering his office packed up and being marched down the hall by his boss Todd, Roger experiences what appears to be termination, only to have Todd shout "Gotcha!" in an elaborate prank. This cruel joke, followed by a real legal meeting, leaves Roger devastated. Such bosses create earthquake-like effects in workplace culture-people scatter, hide, and live in fear of the next incident.
The resulting culture becomes Stage Two, where employees spend energy in quiet protest, using victim language that expresses "my life sucks." Faced with toxic leadership, employees either fight (moving to Stage Three) or "suck it up" to protect career advancement. Many remain trapped, avoiding accountability with phrases like "I'll try" or "That's not possible," their words lacking power to create change.
Middle Stage Two people cluster in tight groups that superficially resemble Stage Four ("we're great") but are actually united by shared victimhood. They believe someone or something permanently blocks their progress-a boss, the system, lack of education, or poor upbringing. The hallmark of middle Stage Two workplaces is Dilbert cartoons decorating cubicle walls and common areas.
Scott Adams, Dilbert's creator, has become the spokesperson for the 25% of American professionals who feel they work for "idiot bosses." In an interview with the authors, Adams explained that evil is built into leadership: "The whole point of leadership is to get people to do things they don't want to do on their own." He argues that his cartoons helped people realize bad management is universal, leading to resignation that organizations are inherently ineffective.
To help people advance from Stage Two, three keys are essential. First, communicate only one stage above-speak the language of "I'm great." Second, identify and work one-on-one with late Stage Two members who want change. Third, encourage formation of dyadic (two-person) relationships. People at Stage Two typically have few strong connections, while Stage Three people form "hub-and-spoke" networks with themselves at center.
Success indicators include using "I'm great" language (with frequent "I" statements), name-dropping, bragging about accomplishments, and exhibiting the lone warrior spirit of Stage Three, often comparing themselves favorably to coworkers.
5장
Stage Three: The Wild, Wild West of Individual Achievement
Stage Three dominates American professional culture, accounting for 49% of workplace tribes. This is the zone of personal accomplishment, where "I'm great" is the dominant mindset. People enter Stage Three when they find their groove, gain confidence, and receive recognition for their talents.
Dr. Martin Koyle exemplifies this stage. A world-class surgeon and department chairman at Children's Hospital in Denver, he has achieved remarkable success-pioneering surgical procedures, leading associations, publishing in top journals, and lecturing worldwide. Yet despite his accomplishments, he feels victimized by a broken system with "zero support" and unfulfilled promises.
Stage Three became dominant in American professional culture between 1890-1920, when the education system was redesigned to mirror factory work. Schools trained children with bell schedules and rewarded those with "right answers" rather than those asking well-designed questions. This system produced conformist workers rather than creative thinkers, breeding the "I'm great (and you're not)" mentality based on grades and individual achievement.
People stabilize in middle Stage Three when they find a group that accepts them for their gifts. They build networks with others they consider at their level, often making statements like "I never got along with people and then realized I was brilliant." Many work in knowledge-based fields where they subtly put down others while promoting themselves as better.
Stage Three comes with significant costs often invisible to those within it. Stage Three bosses are frequently compared to Bill Lumbergh from "Office Space"-detached, passive-aggressive, and treating others as commodities while feeling commoditized themselves. They tend to hire Stage Two employees they can dominate rather than talented peers who might threaten them.
Seven distinct "fingerprints" characterize Stage Three, each with significant costs:
1. You form hub-and-spoke dyadic relationships that require enormous mental energy to maintain
2. You hoard information as power, preventing effective networking
3. You discourage relationships between your "spokes," creating silos
4. You rely on gossip and spies for political information
5. You use military or mafia language that marks you as "immature"
6. You obsessively seek efficiency tools while protecting your turf
7. You talk about "my values" rather than shared values
The result: feeling perpetually time-starved, unsupported, and surrounded by less capable people, while hitting diminishing returns on your efforts.
To break free from Stage Three's limitations, several approaches can help: get honest 360-degree feedback, pursue business education without the "me" focus, find a Stage Four mentor, and recognize when you're merely managing rather than leading. Many who recognize their Stage Three tendencies discover that colleagues are more gifted than previously acknowledged, with executives often realizing "people aren't the idiots I thought they were."
6장
The Tribal Leadership Epiphany: Breaking Through to "We"
The transition from Stage Three to Stage Four requires what the authors call an "epiphany"-a profound realization that transforms one's approach to leadership. Every person who reaches Stage Four experiences this awakening, though it may take different forms and timeframes.
Bob Tobias exemplifies this journey. As a newly elected union president, a reporter's simple question about his plans sparked deep reflection. He realized his career of bitter fights had won institutional victories but changed nothing in workers' daily lives. He had been "working for" union members by "working against" management-his approach required an enemy.
The epiphany unfolds in four distinct phases:
First, leaders recognize their lack of meaningful impact. Despite individual success, they see that their Stage Three approach of "I'm great" isn't creating lasting change. As Ken Wilber of the Integral Institute confirmed to the authors, awareness always precedes feelings or actions in developmental transitions-people conceptualize a different way to operate before knowing how to make it real.
Second, leaders try to fix the problem while still operating from Stage Three. Tobias began preaching collaboration and interest-based bargaining, but his staff ignored him until he realized he wasn't changing his own behavior-he was still the "lone ranger." Though he used Stage Four words like "vision" and "partnership," his sentences still focused on "I" and "me."
Third, leaders ask "What am I really trying to accomplish?" Their answers reveal remarkably similar goals focused on tribal impact rather than personal achievement. David Kelley of IDEO sought to "hang with friends and do things greater than any one of us could do alone," while George Zimmer of Men's Wearhouse emphasized having fun while making a difference. During this phase, professionals reconnect with their original motivations-physicians remember they entered medicine to help people, lawyers to protect rights.
Finally, leaders discover a new relationship with power. They don't back down from difficult decisions but use power not for personal gain but for tribal values. They become more powerful than they were at Stage Three by drawing on tribal convictions and values rather than personal authority.
After the epiphany, a leader's language system realigns from "I" to "we" as they focus on the tribe rather than themselves. They begin listening and speaking for the tribe, accruing respect and followers without attributing success to themselves. The African concept of "ubuntu" captures this essence: "I am because we are"-building the "we" increases a leader's influence, respect and power.
Transitioning from Stage Three to Four requires a leap of faith into an unfamiliar system. Unlike school grades where advancement is mandatory, people can choose to remain in comfortable Stage Three. Tobias advises those in Stage Three to consider their goals: if it's simply to win, stay there; if it's making larger impact, create relationships with others.
The irony is that by abandoning the pursuit of personal victory, Stage Four leaders often achieve everything they sought but couldn't attain at Stage Three: respect, loyalty, and lasting success.
7장
Stage Four: Building Tribal Leadership Through Values
David Kelley, founder and CEO of IDEO, represents an unlikely corporate hero who transformed collaborative design into the world's most successful engineering design company. As a Tribal Leader, Kelley created IDEO as a reaction to dehumanizing Fortune 100 companies, building a culture around innovation, collaboration, communication, and fun.
IDEO operates as a company built from the tribe up, prioritizing its Stage Four culture over traditional corporate structures. New employees are oriented through creative activities rather than formal meetings-making funny hats or doing team-based workshops instead of standard orientation. Everyone functions as equals regardless of experience or position, with the organization paying little attention to boundaries.
Their hiring process involves "lunching" candidates with ten employees who must all commit to the person's success, ensuring cultural and technical fit. Unlike Stage Three companies that merely talk about values, IDEO truly lives them-creating small personal spaces but investing in excellent shared workspaces, demonstrating their commitment to collaboration over individual status.
CB Richard Ellis's Private Client Group (PCG) demonstrates how to create a Stage Four tribe within a larger organization. Glen Esnard established the PCG by identifying emerging leaders ready for Stage Four collaboration. Unlike the traditional "eat what you kill" real estate approach, PCG members pool their client leads into a common database, giving them a "thermonuclear" competitive advantage.
Glen built this collaborative culture systematically: first creating a presentation that appealed to those ready for Stage Four thinking, then having members sign agreements committing to team values, and finally implementing technology that enforced collaboration. When meeting PCG members, Glen consistently connected people in triads, subtly reinforcing relationships between team members.
Sandy Rueve of She Beads offers another model for building Stage Four culture. She transformed from a stay-at-home mom with multiple part-time jobs into the CEO of a multimillion-dollar business built around core values of vitality, quality, and passion. What distinguishes Rueve as a Tribal Leader is her development of "tribal antennae"-the ability to identify contributions from people not yet in the tribe.
These three examples-IDEO, CB Richard Ellis's PCG, and She Beads-demonstrate three paths to establishing Stage Four culture after experiencing the tribal leadership epiphany:
1. Gather like-minded people to create or expand a business (David Kelley's approach)
2. Find people within a Stage Three organization who want to operate at Stage Four (Glen Esnard's approach)
3. Use tribal antennae to identify people across organizational boundaries who want to create a Stage Four tribe (Sandy Rueve's approach)
Most corporate tribes only experience brief moments of Stage Four before falling back to Stage Three. The key to stabilizing at Stage Four involves identifying core values, establishing a noble cause, and building triadic relationships-the necessary foundation before advancing to the most effective final stage.
8장
Core Values and Noble Cause: The Foundation of Stage Four
When former Amgen CEO Gordon Binder speaks about values, his passion exemplifies true Tribal Leadership. Under his guidance, Amgen's culture became "really good, far better than other companies," even as the organization rapidly expanded.
The most important initiative in Amgen's history began when a middle manager, without formal authority, started documenting the company's values. Binder expanded this into a company-wide effort involving hundreds of interviews and focus groups, ultimately identifying eight core values that would guide the organization. "It was the most important thing we ever did," Binder explains. These values became the foundation for hiring, promotion, and termination decisions.
Stable Stage Four tribes must identify and leverage core values while aligning around a noble cause. Everything the tribe does should be sandwiched between these constructs. Projects and initiatives that aren't fueled by values and don't advance the tribal vision should be rethought or eliminated.
When leaders recognize people for their values, the effect is profound. Former Apple Retail COO Kathleen Calcidise recalls having team members write what they admired about colleagues' values, then presenting these appreciations in calligraphy: "A guy had tears in his eyes because he had never been appreciated like that before."
Mike Eruzione, captain of the 1980 U.S. Olympic hockey team, attributes their gold medal not to a "miracle" but to shared values: "strong commitment and work ethic" built on "old-fashioned values." This contrasts with recent U.S. basketball "dream teams" of Stage Three superstars who lost to "lesser" players who reached Stage Four together.
Two effective approaches emerge for identifying values: First, tell a personal story about how you learned a core value, which often prompts others to share their own value-laden stories. The second approach is asking "What are you proud of?" and following with open-ended questions that reveal the values behind achievements.
When Tribal Leaders begin discussing shared values with the group rather than individuals talking about "my values," tribal alchemy occurs. This transforms a collection of individuals into a cohesive tribe with common identity. The behavior and culture reinforce each other-as Patrick Charmel of Griffin Hospital noted, "We don't just talk about our values here; we live them."
If core values fuel a tribe, the noble cause provides direction. NASCAR's Brian France articulates theirs as "Everybody's gotta win"-creating alignment despite independent agents running various aspects of the business. A noble cause represents the tribe's highest aspirations, requiring coordinated action beyond what individuals can accomplish alone.
Two effective methods for developing a noble cause are repeatedly asking "in service of what?" until reaching the highest aspiration, or using the Big Four Questions: "What's working well?", "What's not working?", "What can we do to improve?", and "Is there anything else?"
True Tribal Leadership requires two vital principles: values must be universal (benefiting everyone, not just select groups), and unity must come from alignment rather than agreement. Alignment means pointing in the same direction like magnetized filings, while agreement demands shared intellectual understanding. Tribes based on alignment maximize individual contributions while maintaining directional unity; those requiring agreement discourage learning and independent thought.
Every successful Stage Four tribe conducts regular "tribal maintenance"-quarterly sessions the authors call "oil changes" where members air grievances, ensure alignment between activities and core values/noble cause, and deepen relationships. These sessions help members "fall in love with coworkers all over again" and remember why they love their work.
9장
Triads and Tribal Strategy: The Power of Three
Every September, CB Richard Ellis Vice Chair Darla Longo hosts a remarkable party where she creates three-person interactions (triads) by introducing people to each other based on both professional credentials and personal values, then steps back as they form relationships. While she moves through the room, others speak admiringly about her leadership and vision-the things Stage Three leaders might say about themselves, others say about her after she leaves.
The triad's power lies in its ability to link tribes together, creating unlimited capacity for scalability. Unlike Stage Three's dyadic (two-person) relationships that leave people feeling commoditized and leaders feeling time-starved, triads reorganize the same drive, passion and strategic thinking into more effective structures.
Bruce Cutter, CEO of Cancer Care Northwest, demonstrates how triads resolve conflicts and develop staff while freeing up leadership time. When a staff member complained about a physician not following procedures, Cutter simply said, "You and [the doctor] should work it out. You both want the same thing but see different paths." This approach reminds people of shared values, which trump disagreements.
Angelica Thieriot's experience as a dehumanized hospital patient led her to create Planetree, an organization that revolutionized patient care by forming triads between medical staff, administrators, and patients. After initial resistance, her model proved so successful it spread to 112 affiliate hospitals.
Reid Hoffman, founder of LinkedIn, created a system built on the power of triads in professional networking. His platform allows users to request introductions through mutual connections, creating mini-triads that facilitate business relationships. The authors learned this lesson when trying to contact Hoffman-direct approaches failed, but a LinkedIn request through a mutual connection secured an interview within two weeks.
Four essential practices enable effective triading:
1. Know the values and current projects of everyone in your network
2. Follow Reid Hoffman's "theory of small gifts"-systematically doing little things for people
3. Become genuinely great at something; effective triading requires Stage Three competence
4. Approach triading with authenticity-without the epiphany, triading appears as self-promotion
With values, noble cause, and triadic relationships in place, tribes can develop effective strategies that people actually want to execute. The Tribal Leadership Strategy Map consists of five interconnected components: values, noble cause, outcomes, assets, and behaviors.
Unlike traditional goal-setting, tribal strategy focuses on outcomes-present states of success that evolve over time-rather than goals that imply current failure. As Carl Lewis demonstrated by saying he "ran while others raced," outcomes create a sense of already succeeding rather than striving toward future achievement.
After identifying values and setting preliminary outcomes, tribes must identify their assets-everything they currently possess, from equipment and technology to relationships, reputation, and people's education and networks. Before implementing strategy, tribes must answer "yes" to three critical questions, the first being whether they have sufficient assets to accomplish their outcomes.
In the behaviors discussion, tribes address what actions will accomplish their outcomes. For tribes that answered "no" to having sufficient assets, behaviors should focus on building needed assets. The final test questions examine whether the tribe has sufficient assets to execute the behaviors and whether the planned behaviors will actually work to achieve the outcomes.
Effective tribal strategies work at every organizational level and interlock both downward and upward. Within a Stage Four culture, every person, group and department maintains interconnected strategies that create mutual accountability and partnership.
10장
Stage Five: When Life Is Great
Gordon Binder, former CEO of biotechnology giant Amgen, unknowingly delayed the publication of this book by almost five years. The authors had only identified tribal Stages One through Four with numerous examples of each. They believed Stage Four's "we're great" language represented the pinnacle of tribal development-until their encounter with Amgen completely upended their understanding.
When the authors visited Amgen, they expected to find tribal pride and competitive focus. Instead, when asked about competitors, employees responded with statements like "We're in competition with cancer" and "Maybe our competitor is inflammatory disease." There was no tribal pride or "We're #1" banners-just a whisper-like tone of innocent wonderment. This represented Stage Five, accounting for just under 2 percent of workplace cultures and marked by "life is great" language devoid of competitors.
Jim Clifton, CEO of Gallup, exemplifies this highest level of Tribal Leadership. After acquiring the Gallup name and organization, Clifton moved beyond simply competing with other research firms. The tribe asked, "Are we helping six billion people or just the best corporations?" This question signaled readiness to move beyond Stage Four's competitive focus. Gallup established a new noble cause: "improving the well-being of our clients' organizations and improving the lives of the six billion people on earth."
Stage Five tribes often describe a specific moment when they transcended the "we're great" culture. Mike Eruzione, captain of the 1980 U.S. Olympic hockey team, experienced this when his team beat the Soviet Union. When they faced the Soviets, something remarkable happened-they played not against a competitor but for something bigger: the love of sport, themselves, and their shared values. After winning, there was no tribal pride, only innocent wonderment. "We went back into the locker room, and guys were hugging and crying. We just couldn't believe it," Eruzione recalled in a whisper.
A Stage Five tribe acts like a magnet for groups that can help pursue its noble cause. Organizations like Amgen and Gallup partner with many who don't share their exact values, yet maintain strong commitment to their own values. This isn't contradictory-while Stage Three focuses on "my" values and Stage Four on "our" values, Stage Five operates with "resonant" values. Different organizations with complementary values can work together effectively.
Tribal Leaders often "graduate" to brokering "treaties" between tribes. Figures like Bill Gates, Warren Buffet, Bono, Jimmy Carter, Nelson Mandela, and Desmond Tutu contribute to global causes beyond their original tribes. Some tribes view this departure as betrayal, but these leaders have simply shifted to resonant values. They reference their original tribes like hometowns-places they'll always love but have outgrown.
The examples of early Stage Five represent the highest tribal cultures observed in the research. The authors believe it may be possible to stabilize a tribe at Stage Five, though currently these cultures only exist during history-making projects or when tribes are far ahead of competitors. When situations change, cultures typically regress to Stage Four before advancing again when new opportunities arise.
The authors predict the future of business will be either frequent leaps into Stage Five from Stage Four or breakthrough stability at this level. They've dedicated their professional lives to helping everyone experience Stage Five groups and invite readers who achieve this to share their discoveries.
