Under the Eye of Power by Colin Dickey Summary

Under the Eye of Power analyzes America's enduring obsession with conspiracy theories, arguing they offer illusory order against historical randomness. Colin Dickey traces paranoid narratives from Freemasonry fears to modern QAnon, showing how these ideas reflect societal anxieties rather than reality. Key case studies include the Illuminati panic and 1980s Satanic cult scares.

History enthusiasts, political science students, and readers analyzing modern conspiracy culture will find this book essential. It appeals to those interested in psychological drivers behind misinformation and anyone seeking historical context for today’s “post-truth” climate. Dickey’s accessible style makes complex theories approachable for general audiences.

Yes – the New York Times praises its “intellectually intriguing” analysis, while Kirkus calls it “engrossing.” Dickey’s multidisciplinary approach connects historical patterns to contemporary issues, making it valuable for understanding today’s disinformation crisis. The book received starred reviews from Publishers Weekly for its fresh perspective on American identity.

• Paranoia as comfort: Conspiracy theories simplify complex realities
• Cyclical history: Recurring moral panics from Salem to Pizzagate
• Democratic fragility: How fear narratives erode institutional trust
• American exceptionalism: Unique societal factors enabling conspiracy culture

Dickey positions QAnon as the latest iteration of America’s secret society obsession, comparing its baseless cabal theories to Anti-Masonic movements and Red Scares. He argues these myths persist because they convert societal chaos into tidy narratives of good vs evil, despite contradicting factual evidence.

• American Revolution conspiracy theories about French infiltration
• 19th-century Anti-Masonic political movements
• 1980s Satanic Panic daycare abuse scandals
• Post-9/11 Illuminati resurgence
• 2020s QAnon and election fraud claims

While Ghostland explored haunted locations as cultural metaphors, this book uses conspiracy theories as its analytical lens. Both works examine how communities process collective fears, but Under the Eye focuses specifically on political paranoia’s societal impacts rather than supernatural folklore.

• Publishers Weekly (starred): “Vivid recontextualization of misunderstood history”
• Kirkus: “Colorful history blending comic weirdness with dark insights”
• New York Times: “Intellectually intriguing examination of American anxieties”

Dickey suggests recognizing historical patterns helps break paranoia cycles. He advocates embracing democracy’s inherent messiness rather than seeking false order in conspiracy narratives. The book emphasizes critical media literacy as a tool against disinformation.

With a PhD in comparative literature and expertise in American macabre history (shown in Ghostland), Dickey combines academic rigor with narrative storytelling. His prior work on haunted places and unexplained phenomena laid groundwork for analyzing conspiracy theories’ cultural functions.

• QAnon’s resemblance to 19th-century anti-Catholic conspiracy theories
• Social media’s role mirroring Revolutionary-era pamphlet wars
• COVID misinformation campaigns as updated “Satanic Panic” variants

• Freemasons and Anti-Masonic Party opposition
• The Illuminati’s real history vs conspiracy myths
• Imagined Satanic cults during 1980s moral panics
• QAnon’s fictional “Deep State” cabal