What is
The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century about?
The Rest Is Noise by Alex Ross explores 20th-century classical music’s evolution, linking composers like Strauss, Stravinsky, and Shostakovich to major historical events. It examines how political movements (Nazism, Soviet repression) and cultural shifts influenced modernist, avant-garde, and minimalist works, offering a narrative that intertwines artistry with societal upheaval.
Who should read
The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century?
Music enthusiasts, history buffs, and casual readers seeking to understand 20th-century classical music’s cultural impact will find this book accessible. Ross bridges academic rigor with engaging storytelling, making it ideal for both experts and newcomers.
Is
The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century worth reading?
Yes. Ross’s vivid prose demystifies complex musical trends, offering context for dissonant or experimental works. The book’s blend of biography, politics, and art criticism has been praised for transforming niche topics into a compelling narrative.
How does Alex Ross analyze Shostakovich’s music under Stalin?
Ross depicts Shostakovich’s struggle to create under Soviet censorship, highlighting how his symphonies subtly critiqued Stalinist oppression. This duality—public compliance vs. private dissent—reveals music’s role as both propaganda and resistance.
What role does homosexuality play in
The Rest Is Noise?
Ross examines LGBTQ+ composers like Copland and Britten, linking their identities to their creative output. While some critics argue this focus becomes repetitive, it underscores how marginalized perspectives shaped 20th-century music.
How does Ross critique Schoenberg’s atonal music?
Ross acknowledges Schoenberg’s innovation but questions his rigid serialism, contrasting it with Sibelius’s melodic approach. This analysis reflects broader debates about accessibility vs. experimentation in modern music.
What is the significance of Strauss’s
Salome in the book?
Salome opens the narrative as a symbol of modernity’s birth. Ross details its scandalous 1905 premiere, illustrating how Strauss’s dissonance broke from Romantic traditions and foreshadowed 20th-century musical fragmentation.
How does
The Rest Is Noise address minimalism?
Ross traces minimalism from Reich’s phased rhythms to Adams’s operas, showing its roots in repetitive structures and non-Western influences. He frames it as a reaction against mid-century academic complexity.
What historical events shape Ross’s narrative?
Key events include Weimar Republic chaos, Nazi cultural purges, McCarthyism’s impact on Copland, and Cold War-era avant-garde movements. Ross uses these to explain shifting musical ideologies.
How does Ross describe Messiaen’s
Quartet for the End of Time?
Written in a WWII prison camp, Messiaen’s piece blends apocalyptic imagery with birdsong-like motifs. Ross highlights its spiritual resilience, calling its climactic A-major chord a “supernova” of hope amid despair.
What criticisms exist about
The Rest Is Noise?
Some argue Ross overemphasizes composers’ personal lives (e.g., sexuality) and underserves non-Western traditions. However, most praise its breadth and ability to make esoteric music relatable.
How does
The Rest Is Noise compare to other music history books?
Unlike technical analyses, Ross prioritizes storytelling and context, akin to cultural histories like Gödel, Escher, Bach. It’s often recommended alongside Tim Page’s The Glenn Gould Reader for its accessibility.