Psycho Fae by Jasmine Mas Summary

Psycho Fae is the second book in Jasmine Mas's Cruel Shifterverse trilogy, following Sadie and her alpha teammates—Jax, Cobra, and Ascher—as they fight for survival in the deadly gladiator Fae Games. After being betrayed and captured by the evil Fae Queen, Sadie must compete in brutal combat while uncovering shocking secrets about her destiny and true identity as she navigates the dangerous Fae realm.

Psycho Fae is perfect for readers who love morally gray alpha heroes, strong female characters, extreme enemies-to-lovers romance, and dark fantasy with high heat levels. This book appeals to fans of slow-burn romance with intense action sequences, sarcastic humor, and complex group dynamics. Readers must complete Psycho Shifters (book one) first, as this picks up immediately where the first book ends.

Psycho Fae receives consistently high ratings of 4-4.5 stars from readers who praise its addictive pacing and "just one more chapter" appeal. While some reviewers note the writing isn't literary fiction, they find the unhinged characters, entertaining dialogue, and Sadie's sarcastic humor highly engaging. Readers who enjoyed the first book will find even more excitement, action, and revelations in this installment.

Jasmine Mas is a New York Times bestselling author of fantasy romance whose books have been translated into over 20 languages. She holds a degree in ancient Greco-Roman classical studies from Georgetown University and is a former lawyer who now writes full-time about strong women in magical worlds. She lives in Florida and actively connects with readers on TikTok and Instagram at @jasminemasbooks.

The Fae Games in Psycho Fae are deadly gladiator-style competitions where Faes fight and maim each other for spectator entertainment under the cruel Fae Queen's watch. Sadie and her alphas are forced to participate as captives, facing life-threatening battles while training and competing for survival. These brutal games serve as the central conflict, driving intense action scenes throughout the book while Sadie's group faces constant danger.

Sadie discovers she is more than just a saber-toothed tiger shifter—she's revealed to be a special kind of lost Fae with warrior bloodlines and mysterious powers in her veins. After nearly being beheaded while fighting a vampire, her true nature emerges, suggesting she is a half warrior with abilities that even powerful Faes can sense. These revelations about her destiny fundamentally change her understanding of who she is and set up major plot points for the trilogy's conclusion.

The main love interests in Psycho Fae include Jax (the "mostly normal" member), Cobra (the chaotic psycho alpha), Ascher (who betrayed the group), and Xerxes (the omega who initially hates alphas but shows interest in Sadie). Each character brings distinct personalities to create extreme tension—from homicidal energy to knife fixations—forming what Sadie calls "the problem" rather than a traditional pack. Their complex dynamics and slow-burn romance drive much of the emotional tension.

Psycho Fae escalates the stakes significantly from Psycho Shifters, moving from facility bullies and monster fights to life-threatening gladiator battles in the Fae realm. While the first book focused on Sadie proving her worth, the sequel becomes bloodier and more intense with multiple near-death experiences. The world-building expands into a new magical realm, though readers note they wanted more exploration of the Fae world beyond training and fighting sequences.

Sadie is a badass protagonist with sharp sarcasm, alpha-level confidence, and a violent inner voice that makes readers laugh with her witty internal monologues. She pretends to be as dominant as her male alphas while maintaining vulnerability and insecurity that makes her relatable. Her humor shines through self-deprecating commentary and her infamous inability to run, which becomes a running joke throughout the series despite months of training.

Psycho Fae maintains slow burn tension by giving readers "just a little bit" of spice while building intense sexual chemistry between characters. The alphas even make a "no sex pact" during their captivity, leaving Sadie genuinely worried about dying a virgin despite the palpable attraction. This deliberate pacing frustrates impatient readers but keeps the romantic tension high throughout the deadly games, making eventual intimate moments more impactful.

Critics note that Psycho Fae isn't exceptionally well-written literary fiction and includes repetitive elements like Sadie constantly puking or nearly puking. Some readers find the constant put-downs of the female main character annoying, wishing for more "show don't tell" storytelling approaches. Additionally, the Fae realm feels underutilized—the story could have happened anywhere since most time is spent training rather than exploring the magical world.

The ending of Psycho Fae delivers multiple revelations including Sadie's discovery of her lost Fae heritage and warrior bloodlines after nearly being executed. Aran, the hidden Fae princess, eats "the forbidden snack"—her own mother's heart—in a shocking moment. New characters join Sadie's eclectic group, and the book sets up the trilogy's conclusion in Psycho Beasts with unresolved mysteries about Sadie's full powers and destiny.