What is
Good to Great by Jim Collins about?
Good to Great analyzes how companies transition from mediocrity to sustained excellence. Through a 30-year study of 28 companies, Jim Collins identifies principles like Level 5 Leadership, the Hedgehog Concept, and a culture of discipline as key drivers of long-term success. The book emphasizes strategic focus, disciplined teams, and aligning passion with economic viability.
Who should read
Good to Great?
Business leaders, entrepreneurs, and professionals seeking organizational transformation will benefit from this book. Its research-backed frameworks are particularly valuable for executives aiming to build enduring companies, scale startups, or instill disciplined growth strategies.
Is
Good to Great worth reading in 2025?
Yes. Its principles remain relevant for navigating modern challenges like market volatility and leadership development. The focus on humility-driven leadership and strategic simplicity transcends trends, making it a timeless resource for organizational excellence.
What is Level 5 Leadership in
Good to Great?
Level 5 Leaders combine intense professional will with personal humility. They prioritize organizational success over ego, fostering sustainable growth through team empowerment rather than charismatic authority. Examples include CEOs who credit teams for wins and take responsibility for losses.
How does the Hedgehog Concept work?
This framework guides strategy through three intersecting circles:
- What you can be best in the world at
- What drives your economic engine
- What you’re deeply passionate about
Companies like Walgreens used this to outperform competitors by focusing on convenience over product breadth.
Why does
Good to Great emphasize "First Who, Then What"?
Collins argues that hiring disciplined, self-motivated people precedes defining vision or strategy. With the right team, companies adapt faster to change, as seen in Abbott Laboratories’ turnaround by prioritizing talent over rigid plans.
What is a "Culture of Discipline" in practice?
It involves combining entrepreneurial freedom with systematic accountability. Great companies avoid bureaucracy by aligning teams around core objectives, exemplified by Kimberly-Clark’s focused shift from paper mills to consumer products.
How does the Flywheel Effect create momentum?
Small, consistent improvements compound into breakthroughs over time. Unlike drastic overhauls, this approach builds organic growth, as demonstrated by Circuit City’s decade-long rise to dominance before later missteps.
What are criticisms of
Good to Great?
Some argue its focus on large corporations limits applicability to startups, though Collins addressed this in Great by Choice. Others note 11 of 28 studied companies later declined, highlighting the challenge of sustaining greatness.
How does
Good to Great differ from
Built to Last?
While Built to Last examines enduringly great companies, Good to Great focuses on transitions from good to exceptional performance. The latter introduces new frameworks like Level 5 Leadership missing from Collins’ earlier work.
What key quotes define
Good to Great?
- “Good is the enemy of great.”
- “Get the right people on the bus, then figure out where to drive it.”
These emphasize avoiding complacency and prioritizing talent recruitment.
How can startups apply
Good to Great principles?
By adopting the Hedgehog Concept early to identify niche strengths and cultivating Level 5 Leadership traits in founders. The study found smaller companies share the same success factors as large corporations when scaling.
Why do some good companies never become great?
Complacency with short-term success and lack of disciplined focus often prevent the transition. Collins’ research shows greatness requires confronting brutal facts while maintaining faith in eventual breakthrough.