Question 1

What is They Say / I Say by Gerald Graff about?

Accepted Answer

They Say / I Say by Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein is a guide to academic writing that teaches students how to construct effective arguments through dialogue. The book emphasizes presenting others' viewpoints ("they say") before introducing your own perspective ("I say"), helping writers situate their ideas within broader scholarly conversations. It provides practical templates and strategies to demystify academic writing, making complex argumentative techniques accessible to students across all disciplines.

Question 2

Who should read They Say / I Say by Gerald Graff?

Accepted Answer

They Say / I Say is essential for college students learning academic writing, particularly those struggling to structure persuasive arguments or engage with scholarly sources. The book serves undergraduate and graduate students across all disciplines, from humanities to natural sciences, as it provides adaptable frameworks for discipline-specific writing. English language learners also benefit significantly, as the templates help structure academic thinking and argumentation beyond just grammar and vocabulary.

Question 3

Is They Say / I Say by Gerald Graff worth reading?

Accepted Answer

They Say / I Say is the best-selling composition book of this century, used at over 1,500 colleges and universities with more than one million copies sold. The book's proven framework transforms struggling writers into confident arguers by providing clear templates that reduce the mystery of academic writing. Students consistently report increased confidence and effectiveness in their argumentative writing, making it an invaluable resource for anyone serious about improving their academic communication skills.

Question 4

Who is Gerald Graff, author of They Say / I Say?

Accepted Answer

Gerald Graff is a distinguished professor of English and Education at the University of Illinois at Chicago and one of the most influential education commentators of his generation. Born in Chicago in 1937, Graff earned his B.A. from the University of Chicago and Ph.D. from Stanford University. He co-authored They Say / I Say with Cathy Birkenstein, and his other notable works include Beyond the Culture Wars and Clueless in Academe, all focused on making academic discourse more accessible.

Question 5

What is the "They Say / I Say" framework explained?

Accepted Answer

The "They Say / I Say" framework is a rhetorical structure where writers first present existing arguments or viewpoints ("they say") before introducing their own stance ("I say"). This approach ensures that personal arguments are positioned as responses within broader academic conversations rather than isolated opinions. The framework teaches writers to acknowledge, summarize, and engage with others' perspectives before contributing their own insights, which strengthens critical thinking and creates more persuasive arguments by demonstrating awareness of ongoing scholarly debates.

Question 6

What templates does They Say / I Say provide for academic writing?

Accepted Answer

They Say / I Say offers practical writing templates that serve as rhetorical scaffolding for constructing clear arguments and addressing opposing views. Templates include structures like "In discussions of X, one controversial issue has been whether B" and "While I understand the impulse to A, my own view is B". These formulaic phrases help students make rhetorical moves clearly and logically, distinguishing their arguments from those they respond to while building confidence in academic discourse.

Question 7

How does They Say / I Say help with summarizing and quoting sources?

Accepted Answer

They Say / I Say dedicates substantial guidance to accurately summarizing others' arguments to establish a foundation for your own position. The book teaches writers to create focused summaries that align with their argumentative goals rather than merely listing information. Chapter 3 specifically addresses "the art of quoting," explaining how to select and integrate exact words from sources to launch effective arguments while maintaining the original author's intended meaning.

Question 8

What is metacommentary in They Say / I Say by Gerald Graff?

Accepted Answer

Metacommentary, introduced in Chapter 10 of They Say / I Say, is a technique for clarifying your arguments by commenting on your own writing to ensure readers understand your perspective. This "art of metacommentary" involves explicitly guiding readers through your reasoning, using phrases that signal what you're doing in your argument. The technique helps writers make their intentions transparent, preventing misinterpretation and strengthening the overall coherence of academic papers by directing readers' attention to key points and connections.

更多类似书籍

核心要点

The Hidden Code of Powerful Writing

Mastering the Art of Summary and Response

Strengthening Arguments Through Opposing Views

Making It Matter: Establishing Significance

Creating Flow Through Deliberate Connections

Finding Your Authentic Academic Voice

From Classroom to Life: The Conversation Continues

They Say / I Say by Gerald Graff Summary

Overview of They Say / I Say

Similar books to They Say / I Say

更多类似书籍

核心要点

The Hidden Code of Powerful Writing

Mastering the Art of Summary and Response

Strengthening Arguments Through Opposing Views

Making It Matter: Establishing Significance

Creating Flow Through Deliberate Connections

Finding Your Authentic Academic Voice

From Classroom to Life: The Conversation Continues

快速摘要模式 - 9分钟阅读或收听《They Say / I Say》摘要

闪卡模式 - 《They Say / I Say》精华：10条核心见解

趣味模式 - 《They Say / I Say》的启示 - 19分钟故事

个性化模式 - 0分钟阅读或收听《They Say / I Say》摘要

下载《They Say / I Say》PDF

下载《They Say / I Say》EPUB