Jackson: So, we've seen how Plato helped solve the "God problem" at Nicaea. But what about the "Me problem"? How did these ideas affect how early Christians thought about themselves—their souls, their bodies, their spiritual lives?
Lena: That’s where Neoplatonism comes in. Now, we have to distinguish between "Middle Platonism" and "Neoplatonism." Neoplatonism, which really took off with Plotinus in the third century, took Plato’s ideas and turned the "mysticism" dial up to eleven.
Jackson: Plotinus... I remember he was the one who talked about "The One," right?
Lena: Exactly. For Plotinus, "The One" is the source of everything, and everything "emanates" out from it—like light from a candle. But the further away you get from the light, the darker and more "material" things become. For a Neoplatonist, the goal of life is "return"—to climb back up the ladder of reality through contemplation and mystical union to get back to "The One."
Jackson: That sounds very "monkish." Did this lead to the whole ascetic movement in Christianity?
Lena: It absolutely did. Think about the "Desert Fathers" or the "Stylites" in the East—people like Simeon Stylites who lived on top of a pillar for decades. They were influenced by a mix of Stoicism and Neoplatonism. The idea was that the body is a "receptacle of evil" or at least a distraction from the soul’s true home. By punishing the body, you "free" the soul to ascend.
Jackson: But wait, didn't Christianity emphasize the "resurrection of the body"? If the body is bad, why would God want to bring it back?
Lena: That was the tension! Early Christians like Origen and Gregory of Nyssa were deeply influenced by Neoplatonism, but they couldn't accept it "uncritically." They rejected "absolute monism"—the idea that everything is just a piece of God—and they struggled with the "emanation" view because it made creation seem like an accident or a "leaking" of divine energy, rather than a deliberate act of love by a Creator.
Jackson: So they were trying to keep the Platonic "ladder to heaven" but keep the biblical "God who creates and loves matter."
Lena: Right. And no one did this more famously than St. Augustine. Before he became a Christian, Augustine was a Manichaean—he believed in a dualistic world where good and evil were two equal, warring substances. He thought God was made of "matter," just really refined matter.
Jackson: That sounds like a very "heavy" way to look at God.
Lena: It was! And he hated it. He couldn't figure out where evil came from if God was a material substance. But then, he discovered "the books of the Platonists"—likely Plotinus and Porphyry. It changed his life. From the Neoplatonists, he learned that God is incorporeal—not made of matter at all. And even more importantly, he learned that evil isn't a "thing" or a "substance."
Jackson: If it’s not a substance, what is it?
Lena: It’s a "privation." A lack of good. Just like darkness isn't a "thing"—it’s just the absence of light. This was a massive breakthrough for Augustine. It allowed him to believe in a perfectly good, all-powerful God without making God the "author" of evil.
Jackson: So Plato actually saved Augustine’s faith before he even found Christianity?
Lena: In a way, yes. He called Neoplatonism a "philosophical interim." It gave him the conceptual tools to understand a non-material God. He even said that the Neoplatonists taught him about the Logos, though they didn't know the Logos had "become flesh."
Jackson: It’s like they had the map, but they didn't have the key to the door.
Lena: Exactly. Augustine eventually critiqued the Neoplatonists for their "immaterialism"—their total rejection of the material world. As a Christian, he had to affirm that "God saw that it was good" when he created the world. But he kept the Platonic emphasis on "mystical contemplation." In his Confessions, he describes these moments of "reaching out" with his mind to touch the eternal.
Jackson: It’s fascinating how these "pagan" tools were used to build the most "orthodox" Christian theology.
Lena: It really is. And it wasn't just in the West. In the East, you have the Cappadocian Fathers—Basil the Great, Gregory of Nyssa, and Gregory of Nazianzus. They were steeped in Greek philosophy. They used Stoic ideas about "apathy" (controlling the passions) and Platonic ideas about "theoria" (divine contemplation).
Jackson: It sounds like they were creating a "Christianized" version of the Greek "Ideal Man."
Lena: Precisely. The "philosopher" of the Greek world became the "saint" or "monk" of the Christian world. But they were always careful to say that this "ascent" isn't something we do by our own power—it’s only possible through the Logos. They "baptized" the ladder, so to speak.
Jackson: So we've got the nature of God and the nature of the soul. But what about the nature of knowing? How did they think we could even talk about a God who is "beyond being"?
Lena: That’s the mystery of the "Unknown God," and it leads us straight to one of the most mysterious figures in history: Pseudo-Dionysius.