4
The Most Bizarre Crimes and Punishments in History 9:58 Lena: Miles, we were talking about how humans document the truth, but what about when the "truth" involves putting an animal on trial? I was reading about how in Medieval Europe, from the 800s all the way into the 1700s, people regularly put animals in the witness stand.
10:15 Miles: Oh, the animal trials! This is one of those things that sounds like a fever dream. Pigs, rats, even insects—they were all subject to the full weight of the law. We’re talking formal court proceedings, legal representation, and judges wearing robes.
10:31 Lena: It’s so bizarre because it wasn’t just a joke—they took it with "genuine legal gravity." In 1474, in Basel, Switzerland, they actually put a rooster on trial. Its crime? It allegedly laid an egg, which was considered an "unnatural crime." They found the rooster guilty and publicly executed it.
10:51 Miles: Imagine being the defense attorney for a rooster. What do you even say? "Your Honor, my client was just confused about his biology?" But it wasn't just individual animals. Entire populations of insects could be excommunicated from the church if they destroyed crops. It shows how they viewed the world back then—everything, even a bug, was part of a moral and theological framework where they were held accountable for their actions.
11:15 Lena: It’s a fascinating look at how logic can be built around something completely absurd. If you believe the universe is a strictly ordered place, then a pig killing a child isn't just a tragedy—it's a crime that needs a legal resolution. It’s the same kind of extreme "logic" that led to the Cadaver Synod in 897 AD. This has to be one of the darkest moments in Vatican history.
11:42 Miles: That’s the one where they dug up a dead pope, right?
Lena: Yes! Pope Stephen VI had the body of his predecessor, Pope Formosus—who had been dead for several months—exhumed. They dressed the corpse in papal robes, propped it up on a throne, and literally put it on trial. A deacon had to stand behind the body and answer the charges on its behalf.
12:05 Miles: It’s like a scene from a horror movie. Stephen VI was hurling insults at the corpse, accusing it of perjury and being unworthy of the papacy. Not surprisingly, the corpse lost the trial. They stripped it of its vestments, dressed it as a commoner, and—this is the really grim part—cut off the three fingers on its right hand that were used for blessings. Then they threw the body into the Tiber River.
12:31 Lena: It really shows how power and political rivalry can drive people to these incredible, disturbing extremes. It wasn't about justice; it was a performance to delegitimize a rival. And speaking of weird performances, do you know about the "Dancing Plague" of 1518 in Strasbourg?
12:51 Miles: That one is haunting. It started with one woman, Frau Troffea, who just began dancing in the street. And she didn't stop. Within weeks, about 400 people had joined her.
13:04 Lena: And they weren't just "having a good time." They were dancing with bloody feet, exhausted, some even dying from heart attacks or strokes. The city council’s response was the weirdest part—they decided the dancers had "overheated blood," so their solution was... more dancing. They hired musicians and built a stage!
13:27 Miles: It’s the ultimate "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em" strategy gone wrong. It only made the problem worse. Historians still debate what caused it—some think it was ergot poisoning from moldy rye, which can have LSD-like effects, but it remains one of the most famous cases of mass hysteria. It’s like the "Laughter Epidemic" in Tanganyika in 1962. It started with a few students at a boarding school and ended up affecting over 1,000 people. Schools had to close for months because people couldn't stop laughing—but it wasn't "happy" laughter. They were fainting and in pain.
14:06 Lena: It’s a reminder of how fragile the human mind can be under collective stress. Whether it’s dancing or laughing, these things can spread like a virus. It really puts our modern "trends" into perspective, doesn't it? At least our viral dances don't usually end with us dancing until we collapse.
14:25 Miles: Usually! But history shows us that when things get weird, they get *really* weird. Like the 1904 Olympic Marathon in St. Louis. That whole race was basically a series of bizarre crimes against athleticism.
14:41 Lena: Oh, that race was a disaster! The organizer, James E. Sullivan, actually believed that dehydration was "good" for the body, so he only provided one water station for a 25-mile race in July heat on dusty, unpaved roads.
14:59 Miles: It’s unbelievable. The guy who "won," Fred Lorz, was disqualified because he actually drove part of the way in a car! And the eventual winner, Thomas Hicks, was only able to finish because his trainers were feeding him a mixture of brandy and strychnine—which is literally rat poison—just to keep him moving. He was hallucinating by the end. Only 14 out of 32 runners even finished. It sounds more like a survival experiment than a sporting event.