第1章
When the Kremlin Came Calling
The morning was crisp in Moscow as Donald Trump anxiously checked his phone. It was November 9, 2013, and the Miss Universe pageant he'd brought to Russia was hours away from starting. But Trump's mind was elsewhere-fixated on whether Vladimir Putin would accept his invitation to attend. "Do we know if Putin is coming?" he kept asking his staff. Since announcing Moscow as the pageant location, Trump had been obsessed with meeting the Russian president, even tweeting "Will he become my new best friend?"
What began as a business trip-Trump's brief visit to Moscow to oversee his beauty pageant-would later be scrutinized as the starting point of a relationship that would upend American politics. This encounter, facilitated by an unlikely connection between a gregarious British music publicist and an Azerbaijani pop star, marked the beginning of a saga that would eventually lead to multiple investigations, impeachment proceedings, and what former FBI Director James Comey called "the greatest counterintelligence threat in modern times." Russian Roulette, which became a #1 New York Times bestseller, offers a riveting account of how Russia's interference in the 2016 presidential election unfolded-a story that reads like a political thriller but carries the weight of meticulous investigative journalism.
第2章
Putin's Vendetta: The Origins of Russian Interference
Alexander Litvinenko lay dying in a London hospital bed in November 2006, his body ravaged by radioactive polonium-210. Before succumbing to heart failure, the former FSB officer signed a statement directly accusing Vladimir Putin of ordering his murder. This assassination marked a turning point in Putin's willingness to conduct brazen operations on foreign soil.
Christopher Steele, MI6's top Russia specialist assigned to investigate the case, discovered a pattern connecting Litvinenko's murder to journalist Anna Politkovskaya's assassination weeks earlier-both were outspoken Putin critics. When polonium-210 was identified as the poison-a substance almost exclusively controlled by Russia's nuclear agency-Steele concluded with "80-90% certainty" that this was a state-sponsored assassination ordered by Putin himself. Despite the shocking implications of "nuclear terrorism" on British soil, the international response was tepid-a few expelled diplomats but no meaningful sanctions.
This pattern of Western reluctance to confront Putin would repeat itself for years. When Secretary of State Hillary Clinton implemented President Obama's "reset" strategy with Russia in 2009, Russian chess champion and opposition leader Garry Kasparov warned her, "You're going to waste three to four years." Clinton's diplomatic efforts initially showed promise, including a nuclear arms reduction treaty, but the reset began unraveling after the U.S. intervention in Libya in 2011, which Putin bitterly opposed.
The breaking point came in December 2011, when parliamentary elections in Russia were marred by blatant fraud. As protesters filled Moscow streets shouting "Russia without Putin!" and "Putin is a thief!", Clinton publicly criticized the elections, expressing "serious concerns" and supporting Russians' right to fair elections. Putin took this personally, claiming Clinton had "set the tone" and "given the signal" for the demonstrations. This perceived slight festered into a grudge that would have far-reaching consequences. As one Russian opposition figure later observed, "Putin never forgives and never forgets."
第3章
The Digital Battlefield: Russia's Cyber Warfare Evolution
By 2014, Russia had transformed its intelligence apparatus to wage a new kind of warfare. Russian hackers had previously demonstrated their capabilities by shutting down Estonia's systems in 2007 and infiltrating U.S. Central Command in 2008. These operations aligned with General Valery Gerasimov's hybrid warfare doctrine, which blurred the lines between conventional conflict and political subversion.
The Kremlin also revived Soviet-era "active measures"-disinformation campaigns designed to sow discord in Western societies. When U.S. diplomat Victoria Nuland visited Kiev during the 2014 Ukrainian crisis, she became a prime target. After Ukrainian President Yanukovych abandoned an EU trade agreement under Putin's pressure, massive protests erupted. As the situation deteriorated, Russian intelligence intercepted and leaked a private call between Nuland and Ambassador Geoffrey Pyatt discussing Ukrainian opposition figures, in which Nuland said "Fuck the EU." This provocative release of diplomatic communications signaled Russia's willingness to engage in bold information warfare.
More ominously, a senior Russian official secretly informed U.S. intelligence that Putin had already decided to annex Crimea-a warning that proved accurate when Russian forces seized the peninsula in March 2014. This high-level source also revealed that Putin's inner circle held Obama in racist contempt and was planning a comprehensive campaign to attack Western democracies through cyberattacks, information warfare, and social media manipulation.
The Internet Research Agency (IRA) in St. Petersburg became the centerpiece of this operation. Lyudmila Savchuk, who worked there briefly, exposed how hundreds of employees created fake internet identities to plant stories promoting Putin, ridiculing Russian opposition leaders, and smearing Western politicians. These professional trolls worked twelve-hour shifts creating elaborate personas, stealing photos from real social media accounts to establish credibility. The agency, funded by Putin associate Yevgeny Prigozhin, orchestrated elaborate hoaxes targeting Americans, including a fake chemical plant explosion in Louisiana spread through hundreds of social media accounts.
By late 2014, Russian hackers had penetrated the State Department and White House unclassified networks, stealing documents including Obama's private schedule. NSA deputy director Richard Ledgett described fighting the hackers as "hand-to-hand combat," with the Russians showing unprecedented aggressiveness. Despite this alarming escalation, the Obama administration decided against retaliating, with the president noting, "This is an intelligence operation. It's just like we would do to them." This reluctance to respond forcefully would become a pattern that emboldened further Russian aggression.
第4章
The Trump Connection: Business Dealings and Russian Overtures
Donald Trump's attempts to break into the Russian market spanned nearly three decades, beginning with a Soviet-sponsored trip in 1987 where he explored sites for a Moscow tower. That deal collapsed when Trump refused the Soviet requirement to maintain 51% ownership. Subsequent ventures in 1996 and 1998 similarly failed to materialize, relegating Trump's Russian plans to "the back, back, back burner."
His fortunes seemed to change when he connected with Felix Sater, a Russian-born real estate developer with a troubled past that included a felony conviction for stabbing a man in the face with a margarita glass and participation in a $40 million stock fraud scheme connected to Russian organized crime. Despite this background, Sater and his company Bayrock developed multiple projects with Trump, including the Trump SoHo in New York City.
By December 2015, as Trump led the Republican presidential race, he was actively pursuing a Moscow tower project with I.C. Expert Investment Company-a significant conflict of interest as he sought the presidency while chasing a business venture that required Russian government approval. The deal would have put $4 million in up-front fees in Trump's pocket, with additional percentages of sales. Sater pitched the venture as beneficial to Trump's campaign, boasting he could "get Putin on this program" and help get Trump elected.
When questioned about his relationship with Sater during the campaign, Trump claimed minimal familiarity: "Felix Sater, boy, I have to even think about it." This was a blatant misrepresentation-Trump had worked extensively with Sater for years, even giving him an office in Trump Tower and business cards identifying him as a "senior advisor to Donald Trump."
Beyond Sater, the Trumps pursued multiple angles to exploit Russia's oligarch-driven economy. Donald Trump Jr. made half a dozen trips to Russia in eighteen months, later boasting that "Russians make up a pretty disproportionate cross-section of a lot of our assets" and "we see a lot of money pouring in from Russia." Trump also scored a windfall when Russian oligarch Dmitry Rybolovlev paid $95 million for Trump's Palm Beach estate-netting Trump a $50 million profit after buying it for just $45 million a few years earlier.
As Trump's presidential campaign gained momentum, his team expanded to include individuals with concerning Russian connections. Paul Manafort, who joined as campaign chairman in March 2016, had earned millions consulting for Ukrainian and Russian clients, including work that could "greatly benefit the Putin Government." Michael Flynn, appointed as a national security advisor, had received $45,000 to speak at RT's tenth anniversary in Moscow, where he sat at Putin's VIP table.
第5章
The Hack: Russia Penetrates Democratic Organizations
In September 2015, FBI agent Adrian Hawkins contacted the Democratic National Committee about a potential computer breach. His call was routed to Yared Tamene, an IT specialist with limited cybersecurity expertise who handled basic network administration for the DNC. Despite Hawkins' persistent follow-ups warning that a DNC computer was "calling home" to Russia, the threat wasn't properly addressed for months.
The situation escalated on March 19, 2016, when Clinton campaign chairman John Podesta received a phishing email appearing to be from Google. After clicking the malicious link, Russian hackers gained access to years of his emails. This attack was part of a massive operation by APT 28 (later identified as Russia's military intelligence agency, the GRU), which had targeted thousands including diplomats, military officials, and over 130 Democratic figures.
By April 2016, the DNC finally discovered hackers had accessed their network using Tamene's own credentials. DNC Chief Operating Officer Lindsey Reynolds immediately recognized the significance: "This is the new version of Watergate. This is the way they do it now. You don't need crowbars anymore." The DNC quickly retained cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike, which identified two separate Russian hacking groups: Cozy Bear (APT 29), which had been inside the DNC network since July 2015, and Fancy Bear (APT 28), linked to Russian military intelligence.
The hackers had exfiltrated extensive DNC material, including emails, databases, and the entire opposition research file on Donald Trump. CrowdStrike advised the DNC to maintain normal operations to avoid alerting the hackers they'd been spotted. Officials were instructed to keep the breach secret, even from the Clinton campaign, and use personal email addresses for communications about the hack.
On June 14, the Washington Post broke the story that "Russian Government Hackers Penetrated DNC." The day after, a mysterious figure calling himself "Guccifer 2.0" appeared online, claiming credit for the hack and mocking CrowdStrike's attribution to Russian operatives. This persona posted stolen DNC documents while ominously announcing, "The main part of the papers, thousands of files and mails, I gave to WikiLeaks." Cybersecurity experts quickly dismantled Guccifer's cover story, finding Russian language settings in document metadata and technical evidence linking the hack to previous Russian operations.
The Clinton campaign established a dedicated team under Glen Caplin to handle what they called "dumpster fires"-the steady stream of document releases. Their strategy was to redirect media attention from the documents' content to the Russian interference in American democracy, though many journalists focused on the juicy political details instead. Meanwhile, the White House grew increasingly concerned, ordering intelligence agencies to investigate what they recognized as an unprecedented form of high-tech information warfare.
第6章
The Trump Tower Meeting: Russian Outreach to the Campaign
On June 3, 2016, Rob Goldstone, a British music publicist who had helped Trump with his 2013 Miss Universe pageant in Moscow, sent a fateful email to Donald Trump Jr. He offered "very high level and sensitive information" that would "incriminate Hillary" as "part of Russia and its government's support for Mr. Trump." Trump Jr.'s response was enthusiastic: "If it's what you say I love it." After coordinating with Emin Agalarov, the Azerbaijani pop star whose billionaire father had hosted the Miss Universe pageant, a meeting was arranged at Trump Tower for June 9, with Paul Manafort and Jared Kushner also invited to attend.
The Russian delegation included Natalia Veselnitskaya, a Moscow attorney with Kremlin connections who was leading a lobbying campaign against the Magnitsky Act-U.S. sanctions that had enraged Putin. She arrived carrying a "confidential" memo attacking the law. When they met with Trump Jr., Manafort, and Kushner, Veselnitskaya launched into a discourse about Bill Browder and the Ziff brothers who allegedly financed Democratic campaigns with "dirty money." When Trump Jr. pressed for direct connections to Hillary Clinton, Veselnitskaya admitted she couldn't provide that information. The meeting quickly deflated, with Kushner texting Manafort "Waste of time."
Though unsuccessful in delivering promised dirt on Clinton, the meeting established a connection between the Trump campaign and Moscow, demonstrating the campaign's willingness to accept Russian assistance. This would become a critical focus of subsequent investigations.
The Trump campaign faced other Russian overtures as well. George Papadopoulos, a young foreign policy advisor, met in London with Joseph Mifsud, a Maltese professor who boasted of high-level Russian contacts. After returning from Moscow on April 26, Mifsud told Papadopoulos that Russians had obtained "dirt" on Hillary Clinton: "They have thousands of emails." This revelation came before any public knowledge of the DNC or Podesta hacks. Papadopoulos later revealed this information to Australian diplomat Alexander Downer during a night of heavy drinking in London-a disclosure that would eventually trigger the FBI's counterintelligence investigation.
Meanwhile, Carter Page, another Trump foreign policy advisor, traveled to Moscow in July 2016 to deliver a speech at the New Economic School criticizing U.S. policy toward Russia. Though Page insisted he was speaking as a private citizen, his remarks urged Washington to put aside its "critical tone" toward Putin's regime. During this trip, Page allegedly met with high-ranking Russian officials, including Igor Sechin, the head of state oil company Rosneft. These meetings would later feature prominently in Christopher Steele's intelligence reports.
第7章
The Steele Dossier: A Controversial Intelligence Report
In early June 2016, Christopher Steele, a former British intelligence officer who had handled the Litvinenko case, met with Glenn Simpson, a former Wall Street Journal investigative journalist who now ran Fusion GPS, a private intelligence firm. Simpson, originally hired by the conservative Washington Free Beacon to research Trump, was now retained by Marc Elias, representing both the Clinton campaign and DNC. His simple instruction to Steele: "Tell me what he's been doing over there."
Steele's initial memo contained explosive allegations: Russia had been cultivating Trump for years, offering him real estate deals he declined while accepting intelligence on political rivals. Most shockingly, the FSB allegedly possessed sexual kompromat on Trump from a 2013 Moscow visit involving prostitutes performing a "golden showers" show in the Ritz Carlton's presidential suite where the Obamas had stayed. The memo also claimed Putin personally directed a dossier of compromising material on Clinton.
Despite Simpson's initial reluctance, Steele insisted they share the information with American authorities, arguing this wasn't merely campaign research but "a grave national security threat." Without informing Elias, Steele contacted his FBI connection Michael Gaeta, who flew to London on July 5 after getting State Department approval. Upon reading the report, Gaeta turned white and said simply, "I have to report this to headquarters."
As Steele continued his investigation, his reports grew increasingly alarming, claiming extensive kompromat existed on Trump and alleging an "extensive conspiracy" between Trump's campaign and the Kremlin, managed by Manafort. In September, Simpson and his partner arranged private meetings at Washington's Tabard Inn between Steele and select national security journalists. During these briefings, Steele detailed Carter Page's alleged Moscow meetings, emphasizing that the FBI was taking these reports seriously.
The Steele dossier would later become one of the most controversial elements of the Russia investigation. Though many of its specific claims remained unverified, it raised serious questions about potential compromise of a presidential candidate. A month after Yahoo News published the first story about Page's Moscow meetings, the FBI obtained a secret Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court warrant to monitor Page's communications-a decision that would later become a flashpoint in partisan battles over the investigation's origins.
第8章
The October Surprise: WikiLeaks, Access Hollywood, and Russian Interference
On July 22, just before the Democratic National Convention, WikiLeaks released 20,000 hacked DNC emails, perfectly timed to sow division among Democrats. The emails revealed DNC officials favoring Clinton and deriding Sanders staffers, triggering outrage among Bernie Sanders supporters. Trump gleefully fueled the flames, tweeting that the process was "RIGGED" against Sanders.
As the election entered its final months, Roger Stone, Trump's longtime ally and self-described political dark arts practitioner, became a focus of Democratic investigators. Stone repeatedly boasted about having inside knowledge of WikiLeaks' plans, claiming founder Julian Assange possessed Clinton's deleted emails. When Stone tweeted "Trust me, it will soon be Podesta's time in the barrel," Clinton's team feared their worst suspicions were confirmed.
By September, CIA Director John Brennan had become convinced Russia was mounting an aggressive effort to interfere in the election. Seeing troubling intelligence about contacts between Russian officials and Trump associates, he formed an interagency working group with experts from NSA and FBI to share sensitive information. The intelligence consensus was clear that Russian state-sponsored hackers were behind the cyberattacks, though questions remained about whether the operation came from the top and what Moscow's primary aim was.
At the first principals meeting, Brennan delivered shocking news: intelligence indicated Putin personally ordered the cyber operations targeting the U.S. election. This information was so sensitive it hadn't even been included in the President's Daily Brief. Despite this revelation, the Obama administration struggled with how to respond without appearing partisan during an election where Obama was campaigning for Clinton.
October 7, 2016, became a pivotal day in the campaign. The Department of Homeland Security and Office of the Director of National Intelligence released an unprecedented statement officially attributing the election hacking to Russia, declaring that "only Russia's senior-most officials could have authorized these activities." The Clinton campaign was ecstatic about the statement, which validated what they'd been saying for months.
However, within hours, two bombshells overshadowed this revelation. First, the Washington Post published the Access Hollywood tape showing Trump making lewd comments about sexually assaulting women. Then, just 30 minutes later, WikiLeaks released the first batch of John Podesta's emails-timing that appeared strategically designed to distract from the Trump tape scandal.
The emails contained damaging content: Clinton advocating for "open borders" in a hemispheric common market and describing herself as "far removed" from her middle-class upbringing. Most damaging was her statement about needing "both a public and a private position" in politics. Despite Clinton's team trying to focus attention on the Russian attack, media coverage focused primarily on the emails' content rather than their suspicious source.
第9章
The Aftermath: Election Results and Ongoing Investigations
On Election Night, Clinton won the popular vote by nearly 3 million votes, but Trump secured an Electoral College victory with razor-thin margins in Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania-just 77,000 votes across these three states. In Moscow, the Russian Duma burst into applause when Trump's victory was announced. As one Russian writer exclaimed, "This is the real reset, not the Clinton reset. This is the real reset of the Western world."
After the election, Obama ordered a "full review" of Russian election interference to be completed before leaving office. The CIA had concluded Russia's cyberattacks were specifically aimed at electing Trump. White House aides and Congress members rushed to preserve intelligence documents before Trump could potentially bury them.
On December 29, Obama finally announced sanctions against the GRU, FSB, and senior Russian officials. The State Department closed two Russian compounds used for intelligence operations and expelled thirty-five suspected Russian operatives. Michael Flynn, Trump's incoming national security advisor, immediately called Ambassador Kislyak, urging Russia not to retaliate and promising better relations once Trump took office.
The intelligence community's final assessment concluded with "high confidence" that Putin had ordered an influence campaign to undermine faith in American democracy, damage Clinton, and help Trump. The report detailed the comprehensive Russian operation: cyberattacks, WikiLeaks dumps, fake online personas, troll farms, and state propaganda outlets.
On January 6, 2017, intelligence chiefs briefed Trump on their findings. After the others left, FBI Director Comey privately briefed Trump on the Steele dossier. Trump immediately declared the allegations false and later concluded Comey was attempting to blackmail him-a perception that would eventually lead to Comey's firing.
Throughout his first year in office, Trump deployed the phrase "witch hunt" to counter the mounting investigations, tweeting about Russia over a hundred times and calling it a "hoax." Rather than punishing Putin, Trump's early directives shocked State Department officials, as he sought to improve relations with Russia and potentially ease sanctions.
The firing of James Comey on May 9, 2017, backfired spectacularly, raising obstruction of justice concerns and leading to the appointment of Robert Mueller as special counsel. Mueller assembled a team of experienced prosecutors specializing in organized crime, money laundering, and white-collar crime. By the end of 2017, Mueller had indicted Paul Manafort and Rick Gates on multiple charges, while George Papadopoulos and Michael Flynn had pleaded guilty and begun cooperating with investigators.
Despite mounting evidence of Russian interference, Trump continued to express doubt about Russia's role and showed more concern about Putin's feelings than Putin's aggression. After meeting Putin at the G20 summit in Hamburg, Trump told reporters, "He said he didn't meddle. I really believe that when he tells me that, he means it." This stance provided Putin cover and ensured no meaningful penalties for Russia's attack on American democracy-leaving nothing to stop future attacks.
Russian Roulette reveals a troubling pattern: a hostile foreign power successfully interfered in an American presidential election, yet partisan divisions prevented a unified response. Whether through direct collusion or unwitting assistance, the Trump campaign benefited from and encouraged Russian interference, while the Obama administration's cautious approach failed to deter Russian aggression. The consequences of this unprecedented attack on American democracy continue to reverberate through our political system today, raising fundamental questions about national security, election integrity, and the resilience of democratic institutions in the digital age.
![Russian Roulette: The Inside Story of Putin's War on America and the Election of Donald Trump [Paperback] [Jan 01, 2018] Michael Isikoff, David Corn book cover](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fd1y2du6z1jfm9e.cloudfront.net%2Fcovers%2F24541325-333c-4814-9da4-2a9edffc567d%2Fimage_resized.webp&w=1024&q=75)
